Specialization May Create a Lot of Familial Instability

This is just a quick thought, but it occurred to me that in the olden days, when people commonly did one of only a few dozen jobs and most of them were local, that allowed a greater amount of stability in terms of people living near their extended relatives. In the modern world, with so much specialization, people may need to travel quite far in order to find an opening in their field. For some fields, this is simply unavoidable. For the foreseeable future, a heart surgeon must go to a hospital where there is an opening for a heart surgeon. But for many jobs, it may be possible that the increasing ability of jobs to be done remotely may counterbalance this.

The industrial revolution seems, as we are entering its later phases, to have something of a horseshoe pattern in terms of its push to centralization. At first, it had an enormously centralizing effect; factories were more efficient when they were bigger and eventually we saw gargantuan factories like the mile-long factories of Bethlehem Steel. With these massive factories came massive organizations with enormous hierarchies. And these also had a massive geographic localizing effect as it was advantageous to factories to be located near where their inputs came from, or at least on the same river system, as we saw with the car companies being located where the steel could come to them.

A second-order effect to this was the requirement for massive amounts of capital to build factories. Factories the size of small cities are not cheap to build, and so this centralized things even further with “how on earth do we raise the capital to get a gigantic factory built and then actually get it built?” being a massive economic question in the 1800s and early 1900s. (That second part of the question is at least as significant as the first, as the California “track to nowhere” shows, it’s quite easy to spend enormous amounts of money and have nothing to show for it. People want factories, not empty bank accounts; the empty bank account is just something they’re willing to trade to get a working factory. But no one wants non-functioning quarter-factories.)

But as the wheel of history turned, the giant steel factories were replaced by far more “micro mills”—electric arc steel furnaces that made steel more cheaply and in smaller batches, which could be placed closer to where they were needed. This went on, with industrial robots allowing people to get more work done per human being, and more recently things like additive manufacturing (“3D printing”) have made it possible to have tiny factories run by only a few people. And the internet has made much of the administrative side of things—things like engineering, accounting, and so on—possible to do from great distances.

I was put in mind of this as I was talking with my father and we were discussing family history and for so many relatives the story ended with “he moved away for a job and we lost touch.” So I wonder if the late-stage industrial revolution tending towards less centralization will amelioriate some of the damage done in this aspect, too. It won’t do that completely any time soon—the heart surgeon will probably need to wait a long time to remotely guide a surgical robot—and some jobs that simply need a human connection will tend to have a disruptive effect. But it will be better for society, I think, when that is far more of the exception than the rule.


Discover more from Chris Lansdown

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.