When Housework Goes Unrecognized

A problem faced by anyone who lives together, even simply as roommates, is that people are very conscious of the housework that they themselves do, but not nearly so conscious of the housework that other people do. This is often exacerbated in marriages because males and females frequently have variations in their priorities of what they notice. But even without sexual differences, there is a natural tendency of human beings to take advantage of a division of labor to reduce mental strain by not noticing the things that we’re not responsible for. Unfortunately, that often has the side effect of meaning that we don’t appreciate the housework of the people we live with, and it can even lead to incorrectly feeling taken advantage of by incorrectly believing we’ve done a significantly disproportionate share of the work.

A common solution to this problem is complaining. This tends to be as ineffective as complaining normally is unless it happens within the context of a marriage, where it is usually less effective than complaining normally is. While “opposites attract” is an overly reductive cliche, it is true that people instinctively look for a spouse who will complement rather than duplicate them, and so divisions of labor within a marriage tend to split along these complementary lines. But the very thing that makes the people complementary here tends to make it harder for them to notice the thing that comes more easily to their spouse; in general one finds it more comfortable doing a task where one effortlessly notices its parameters.

There is a much better solution, though it only functions within a specific general attitude to life: generosity rather than entitlement. If your attitude is, “people should do what they should and I shouldn’t have to be grateful to them for fulfilling their responsibilities,” I’ve got nothing to offer you, except perhaps my sympathy because that sounds like a miserable way to live. Focusing on the minimum one is required to do rarely leads to happiness. That said, I’m no man’s master and it’s not my goal to tell anyone else how to run their life.

In the happy alternative, dear reader, that you are open to the idea of being grateful for good things done for you, even where people have an obligation to do them, then there is a fairly easy solution to the problem of unrecognized housework: when you do it, tell the other person about it. The trick is in how you tell them.

Let us suppose that you have an arrangement with your housemate that you will clean the dishes and they will sweep the floors. Suppose that this afternoon they swept the floors. This makes the house you live in more pleasant to be in, so it is a benefit to you. That is, your housemate recently made your life a little better. It’s nice to live with people who put themselves to inconvenience in order to make your life better, isn’t it? Yes, of course there were other benefits, too. Do other people benefiting reduce the benefit you received in any way? Of course not. The whole world could be 1000 times happier to live in for everyone in it, and the benefit you received of living in a cleaner house would not be diminished in any way, and so you are completely free to be grateful for this benefit without regard to who else might have benefited from it. And the proper reaction to receiving a benefit is gratitude; gratitude is really nothing more than the recognition of having received a benefit from someone.

Now, let us suppose that your housemate cleaned the floor while you were out of the house, and let us suppose you’re not in the habit of examining the floors so you didn’t notice. You were preoccupied with some thought, so your feet not stepping on uncomfortable crumbs manifested not as a surprise at how clean the floor was, but as your thoughts being uninterrupted. This is practical, but it’s not entirely ideal, because you received a benefit for which you have failed to be grateful. That’s not a big deal, but all else being equal, it would be better for things to have gone perfectly, wouldn’t it? So imagine that, after your housemate warmly greeted your return, they cheerfully added, in a voice much like one giving somebody a small birthday present, “by the way, I swept the floors earlier.”

This small, cheerful communication said in a way that clearly doesn’t require anything of you has now given you two benefits:

  1. It lets you know that you received a benefit and the person who did it understood the benefit to you and intended it; another human being in the world wants you to be happy
  2. You are now equipped with the knowledge to be grateful in a situation where you should be.

In this spirit, your housemate cheerfully giving you this information would make your day a little better, wouldn’t it? You would now have two benefits, both of which you’re aware of, rather than just one which you were unaware of. So, all things considered, it would be nice if they were in the habit of doing that, wouldn’t it?

Here’s the thing: all of that applies in reverse, too. And while you can’t—or at least shouldn’t—form habits for other people, you certainly can for yourself. Any time you do some housework, it only takes a tiny bit of extra effort to think about how the people who live in the house (or apartment) will benefit. And at some time it would be convenient for your housemate, it takes equally little effort to cheerfully tell them that things are that little bit better now. If you have trouble focusing on the benefit, this is one of those cases where the passive voice can be helpful. You don’t need to say “I did the dishes,” though there’s nothing in the world wrong with that. Go ahead and say, “the dishes are clean.”

It’s worth noting that this is actually a lot more important than getting credit. It’s important to make sure that your housemate knows about what you’re doing so that they feel like they’re part of a human community which is taking care of them. Them being aware of the work that others do which benefits them actually makes them feel safe and valued.

There is a strange but fundamental tension in human relationships—it is bad to brag but also bad to hide the good that one does for people. Jesus rather famously gave two contradictory commands:

  • When you give alms, don’t let the left hand know what the right is doing
  • Do not put your light under a bushel-basket

They’re not actually that hard to reconcile if you pay attention to the stuff around it; about giving alms Jesus said to not blow a trumpet before you. That is, don’t attract the attention of people who don’t need to know. But if you give food to a hungry man, you do need to make sure he knows he has the food, otherwise he can’t eat it.

When you live with a person, part of your duty is to make them feel like they’re part of a functioning human community which values them. If they’re unaware of the work you do to take care of the household, you may be doing your housework but you’re failing in your responsibility to make them feel cared for. And the thing is, you can’t do that through alternatives. A person won’t feel cared for if they feel like they’re the only one doing anything to keep the house from falling apart but you occasionally give them a cordless drill. Not everything is interchangeable; a child won’t feel fed if you don’t give them food but brush their hair three times a day, even if they have long hair and it takes longer to brush their hair than it would take to make a sandwich.

When housework goes unrecognized, the solution is to be more generous. But as in so many things, be generous about things that people actually need, not about what’s merely convenient to give.

Addendum: Navigating An Existing Relationship

Many people consider this problem because they are already in it, and in that case there is a little that needs to be said about how to transition to this approach because there can be some pitfalls. That said, the single most important thing to any successful transition is consistency: the glory and the shame of the human race is that we can get used to anything. Just as flowing water wears down rocks, consistent behavior will eventually wear down the hardest-nosed skepticism.

That said, it can speed things up quite a bit to adapt one’s words to the circumstances. The most common failure mode is that things have degenerated into a transactional relationship where both people feel that they put in far more than the other person. In that context, they’re primed to take any mention of things the other person does as a drop in the bucket being presented as if it’s a full bucket—that is, they’re likely to expect any mention of what you did as meaning that this one thing balances out everything they’ve done. There are two main things to do in order to speed up them accepting your words in the spirit in which they’re intended.

The first thing is to minimize the time and attention spent on telling them. One of the most effective ways to do this is to sandwich it between an introduction and a practical question. For example, “Man, it was a long day today. But I did manage to get the floors swept. Any ideas where we should eat for dinner?” By pre-empting them thanking you with a practical question to answer, you negate the impression that you’re telling them in order to be thanked. Them thanking you puts greater emphasis on what you did, because of the extra time spent; that being in excess of the time spent talking about what they did is what tends to lead to thinking that this is meant to balance everything out.

The other big thing is to make a point of showing gratitude for what they did when they tell you about it. If your housemate tells you that they swept the floor and your response is cheerful thanks or cheerful praise, they will naturally assume that when you tell them about what you did, it’s in the same spirit. The worst thing to do is to bring up housework that you did as if it’s a counter-argument. That will confirm their worst suspicions. It is workable, though probably best to avoid in the beginning, to genuinely thank or praise them, then mention a bit of housework you did, as long as you can make it sound like it’s a team accomplishment and the team is celebrating its shared victories. But as I said, try to avoid that in the beginning. There’s plenty of time to mention what you did, and putting a little space between it and the celebration of what they did is almost always the safer policy.

If you can manage to notice housework that they did before they mention it, thanking them for it before they say anything about it will be an especially powerful framing tool for when you later bring up what you did. And the good news, here, is that not only do you not need to do this for everything, that’s actually a bad idea. People don’t like to feel like they’re being watched, because that means that the one watching will notice the moment they’re imperfect. Occasionally noticing and volunteering thanks is the ideal cadence (in this fallen world) because it communicates that there is both appreciation and slack, and we all need people to cut us slack from time to time.

Parents Can’t Give Their Children What Doesn’t Exist

There was plenty that was wrong with the Baby Boomer generation, but I’ve noticed that they frequently get blamed for all sorts of things that were not their fault. Many of the things I’ve seen like this are related to things that happened while they were children (e.g. no fault divorce was first signed into law in the USA by Ronald Reagan when the oldest Baby Boomers were 23 and most weren’t even adults). But some of them either didn’t happen or happened a long time before the Baby Boomers were even born. In that latter category is the complaint that the Baby Boomers had smooth lives on a script that worked beautifully then either didn’t give their children that script or dismantled it so they wouldn’t need to give up their own privileges. There’s plenty that the baby boomers did wrong, but this is just ahistorical nonsense. The script for life stopped working before their own parents were born and the Baby Boomers had a rough start in adulthood.

There was a time, long ago, when parents could (basically) hand their children a script for how to live a decently successful life, in terms of reliably providing for the physical necessities of life, assuming that no disasters like famines, plagues, floods, earthquakes, massive storms, forest fires, or invading armies intervened. And in the pre-industrial world where those life scripts were possible, those things often did intervene to mess up the script. But, in spite of the relative prevalence of disasters, there was a script you could follow and do about as well as anyone else born to a similar station in life.

But then the industrial revolution hit and the world started changing rapidly. Entire professions got wiped out because industry could make the same things vastly cheaper (and as time went on, often better). This was even true of farming—the standard script for most people in most of recorded history. Between farming machinery like tractors and the availability of large quantities of fertilizer (originally bird guano transported from tropical islands, then after world war 1, synthetic fertilizers) it became possible for a small fraction of the population to make more food than everyone needed. This created tons of opportunities, but it also destroyed the script. Even if you did the job your father did, you couldn’t do it the way he did it.

Trying to follow an economic life script became a major liability in the 1800s and a great deal of literature of the plight of the working man is about trying to construct new life scripts in a rapidly changing world. Interestingly, another genre of literature from the same time was looking at the most outstanding successes of the men who threw away the script and constantly adapted to the circumstances in front of them. The hagiographies of men like Andrew Carnegie (who started as a bobbin boy in a factory and constantly adapted to circumstances so well he became one of the richest men in the world) have largely become historical relics, as far as I can tell, but they were popular in their day. And they were popular precisely because they inspired people to throw away the script and adapt to the changing world. It’s both difficult and scary to do that.

By the time of the Baby Boomers, their parents didn’t try to give them an economic life script because it was obvious it wouldn’t be useful. Instead, they tried to give them the tools to adapt to rapid change: education and discipline.

These are the tools to adapt to a rapidly changing world because there is a universal truth:

Discipline creates opportunities.

They are rarely the opportunities you expect.

Discipline consists of the ability to control oneself; when you cannot rely on the rest of the world the only thing left in the world you can rely on is yourself. If the ground is unstable, you can only stand upright through your own balance; when the ground shakes your ability to keep your torso over your legs is what keeps you from falling. But that only works if you have the discipline to make yourself reliable. If you do, then the changing world becomes full of opportunities, just as geological upheaval is why paleontology can be done with picks and shovels rather than tunnel boring equipment. (Though, ironically, plenty of paleontology takes advantage of the tunnels that other people bore.)

Now, if you want to talk about the actual faults of the Baby Boomers, it turned out that many of them really didn’t like self-discipline. Even the ones who did were often hesitant to teach it to their own children. Their children, in turn, were (often) even more reluctant to teach it to their children. And young people now are often the victims of this; they were not raised to view society as a bewildering mess of opportunities if they’re bold enough, knowledgeable enough, and disciplined enough to identify the opportunities and grab them.

Young people these days were neither given a script nor were they trained to be able to live without one. Or, worse, they were handed a script that only works for a lucky few.

If you really want to blame the Baby Boomers for something, blame them for thinking that childhood is supposed to be happy instead of a difficult preparation for being able to survive a challenging and chaotic world. Blame them for letting people think that authorities can be trusted and comfort is normal. Blame them for letting you think that security is possible in this harsh world where the best case is that you grow old and frail and eventually die from a heart attack or cancer if something else doesn’t get you first. Blame them for thinking religion is dangerous because of religious wars without considering that the world has many more secular wars.

Because the only way this world makes any sense is as a preparation for eternity. It doesn’t work on its own, and it fundamentally can’t. The only way to be happy in this world is to be constantly looking for what will work for now, and whether that buys you enough time to figure out the next thing that will work.

If you really want to blame the Baby Boomers for something, don’t blame them for not passing on an economic life script. There wasn’t one for them to give you. Blame them for not prominently mounting a skull in the living room and for not frequently telling you:

Remember, O man, you are dust, and to dust you shall return.

Parasitic Condescension

A pattern I’ve observed is people who are relatively high in intelligence but low in social skills often have trouble finding other highly intelligent people with whom they can converse as equals, thus having something to offer, and so they find people who have something fairly wrong with them and trade acceptance for friendship. I believe this generalizes, which may be the more interesting part, but I want to focus on the particular example for the moment.

The problem that a highly intelligent person has is that they are not naturally interesting conversational partners for more ordinary people. They tend to engage with subjects on a level of detail that doesn’t work for most people, and when they make the basic move of friends—attempting to share the good they see in the world to share in its enjoyment together—with ordinary people they tend to do it in ways that don’t work for the other person. Now, finding the level that works for the other person and adjusting to it is a learnable skill, but it’s not an easy skill, and many intelligent people aren’t good at it. Which means that, with most people, they don’t have much to offer as friends. It doesn’t matter that this is because they can see so much more; the relevant point is that, as a friend, they offer very little. And worse, the highly intelligent person doesn’t just offer less. Because they will talk at length in ways that are hard to follow, they actually cost more.

Now, if the highly intelligent person can find another highly intelligent person, they can offer quite a lot as a friend. But especially when people are looking locally, they just don’t run into other such people very often. So what is the highly intelligent person to do, given that they have relatively little to offer as friends? (Other than read extensively where they can meet other intelligent people who are removed by time and space, I mean.)

One common solution is to look for desperate people. People who have something wrong with them. It’s not hard to find desperate people who are a bit more intelligent than average, which will give the illusion of compatibility. And in exchange for the other person accepting the more intelligent person as a friend, the more intelligent person can give acceptance of whatever is wrong with the desperate person (terrible social skills, self-destructive behavior, crippling self-doubt/fearfulness, and complete unwillingness to see things from other people’s perspective are relatively common, from what I’ve seen). There’s a decent chance that the highly intelligent person can do this because their high intelligence allows them to bridge more gaps.

I suspect that this generalizes towards significant differences in social status where the higher status person is not accepted by the current hierarchy, at least not as high as they want to be. So they can trade (at least apparent) acceptance of an out-group for support by that group which can potentially elevate them to the level that they want. This may well describe many cases of “advocacy” that we see, where a person attempts to make themselves a hero for some group or other. The fundamentals are an apparently asymmetric trade where the lower trading partner is generally under-valued and so the higher trading partner is able to get greater value than it seems like they would.

I strongly suspect this general pattern is visible in many places in life. It is also highly distinct from true condescension (in the etymological sense of coming-down-to-be-with, as in the Incarnation, for example) where the higher person lowers themselves for the good of the lower person.

Scolds, We Will Always Have With Us

When I was young, it was common for people to blame Christianity in particular or religion in general for the existence of scolds. It never seemed to occur to these people that scolds love to scold people, and will use whatever seems to them the dominant moral framework to scold people.

Scolds need to be distinguished from more general manipulators, who will also use whatever they perceive to be the dominant moral framework of the time to get what they want. For example, suppose a person who is often late and doesn’t want to just apologize for it will try to get people to stop complaining about it. If people are very concerned with racism, they’ll figure out how objecting to them being late is racist. If people are concerned with communism, they’ll figure out how objecting to them being late is communist. If people are concerned with demons, they’ll figure out how objecting to them being late is demonic. They are using whatever is popular, but, unless they’re lucky, the connection is often extraordinarily tenuous.

Scolds tend to operate differently. They stick closer to whatever the dominant moral paradigm is, but make no allowances for context—or implicitly throw away every other concern. Since a human being must balance out all of the virtues in order to live well, this means that they will always do things below the standard of the scold, who makes no allowances for that balance. Thus the scold always has the opportunity for the pleasure of telling somebody else what’s wrong with them.

If one tried to prevent the scolds by getting rid of all rules whatever, the scold would probably just start hurting people by hitting them with whatever sharp objects were ready to hand, since this would no longer be against society’s rules. Such a life would, of course, be, as the saying goes, “nasty, brutish, and short,” but the scold would die with Ahab’s words on his lips, “From hell’s heart I stab at thee; for hate’s sake I spit my last breath at thee.”

There will be no escaping the scolds until the end of time when the angels bind up the weeds and cast them into the fire. And one can only escape the scolds then if one is not a weed oneself. And, after all, that’s the thing each of us actually has control over.

Caroline Furlong on Men Expressing Emotions

I came across this very interesting post by Caroline Furlong when I noticed that she had linked to my post Women Want Men To Show Emotion. I recommend reading her post in full, it’s very interesting:

The one thing I would note about her description of how men deal with anger is that—for very understandable reasons, given that her primary focus is writing fiction—she is mostly describing how young men deal with anger. (Oversimplifying: finding a legitimate target for aggression like a punching bad or wood that needs to be chopped.)

Turning into an adult greatly amplifies the intensity of the feelings one experiences (this is one reason why it’s so hard to be a teenager) and young men aren’t used to this yet. Also, if they’ve been raised at all well they’ve been taught self control, but it’s still a relatively new skill. So finding a legitimate target for aggression serves a purpose they mostly don’t realize it does: physical exhaustion. When an angry man hits a legitimate target over and over until he’s exhausted, this doesn’t directly help him to process the emotions. What it does is physically exhaust him. This counteracts the physical arousal that comes with anger, giving him the ability to think clearly—at least until he recovers his energy. Which is why it’s so important for him to actually do some thinking once he’s tired. This is also why this is where you usually see the older man come talk to him and he’s somewhat receptive. Once he’s tired, he can think, and the older man gets him to do it. Then he leaves and gives the young man time to think about what was just said. But very frequently the scene ends with the young man, who is now somewhat physically recovered, hitting things again. That’s because the physical arousal that returns as his exhaustion dissipates is clouding his ability to think again.

As men get older and more experienced, the physical arousal diminishes slightly but more importantly it’s familiar. In the same way that older men tolerate pain better than younger men do because it doesn’t scare them, older men deal with anger better because it doesn’t distract them so much. This allows them to get to the part that actually helps with the feelings more directly: thinking about the problem. Thinking it through, thinking about whether it was perceived correctly, thinking about how to handle it, thinking about how to handle all of the possible outcomes, etc. This is what actually helps a man deal with the emotion of anger: understanding what caused it and how to deal with it; having a plan for dealing with it.

It is possible that there’s too much to think through for a short time, of course, in which case one needs to think about it in the back of one’s mind while doing other things. When this is the case, thinking about it in the foreground of one’s thoughts is helpful occasionally—almost to check in on one’s progress in figuring it out—but it’s unhelpful or even counter-productive most of the time. In these cases a man will need to distract himself, and will usually do so with some kind of problem solving. Preferably, by doing something useful, but things like video games can also work. The critical thing to understand about this is that it’s not the man refusing to deal with his problems. It is, in fact, the man dealing with this problems. It’s just him dealing with the problems slowly, because that’s the only way that will work. It’s a bit like sleeping on a big decision like buying a house or a car. It’s not that your internal monologue is all about the purchase, but you are none the less doing something useful; if no objections occur to you in that time period it is much more likely to be a good decision. In like manner, when there’s some really big problem making a man angry, shoving it to the back of his consciousness and focusing on other things helps his mind to sort it out. Sometimes what you need are to make connections to things you don’t remember, but over time will think of and then see the connection. But the critical thing to realize is that this is actually quite constructive. If you force to him only think in the foreground of his mind about the thing making him angry, he won’t be able to pull together the various threads of his knowledge and thoughts necessary to really understand his problem and formulate a plan to deal with it. And he will feel awful until he does that. This is why a man talking about his feelings is often not just unhelpful but outright counter-productive. It’s getting in the way of doing the thing that will make him feel better, and emphasizing all of the stuff that makes him feel bad.

Anyway, that’s just an addendum to what Ms. Furlong said. Go read the post, it’s very much worth the time.

Women Want Men To Show Emotion

A few days ago a tweet went viral about men showing emotion:

wish men understood how attractive it is when they can feel & openly show their emotions instead of acting like a sociopathic brick wall

A great many people objected to this because, if a man follows this simply as described, the results are pretty much always a disaster. That’s because there’s a communication gap going on. What she wants is not, in fact, men “openly showing their emotions.” Men have very big emotions and many of them women would find terrifying if exposed to the full force of them. Also, if you’re speaking in the context of people who are merely dating, a man blubbering, out of control, will probably kill any attraction that the woman felt to him.

What she’s actually talking about but not saying clearly is that she wants communication. There’s an old saying in writing fiction that when people give feedback about your story, they’re usually right in what the problem is and wrong about what the solution is. This is a good example of that. If you ignore the suggested solution and focus on the problem, you can see that it’s a real problem.

instead of acting like a sociopathic brick wall

If you focus on this part, you can see that this is a legitimate problem. If a man does not communicate anything about his emotional state, at any time, to any degree, his wife will have no idea what’s going on, where he stands, where they stand, whether she can support him, whether it’s a good time to ask for things that eventually need to be done, etc. etc. etc.

And bear in mind that when I talk about her supporting him, I’m not primarily talking about giving him a shoulder to cry on so he can “get it out.” Men mostly don’t work that way. We don’t “get it out.” Talking about feelings does not exhaust them, or reduce them, or put them in perspective. If anything, it amplifies them and makes them harder to deal with. But within a marriage, there are many things each spouse does to support the other. This can range from things like getting the other one a food they particularly like to spending time with them in a way that’s relaxing or fun to letting them know that you’re fine with any outcome. (“Even if it doesn’t work out, we’ll be fine” can take a lot of stress out of many situations.)

For this and other reasons, reliable communication about how the man is doing, emotionally, is extremely helpful to his wife. (I’m talking about wives; all of this is merely prospective when it’s about a girlfriend because she is subconsciously evaluating what life will be like as a wife.) But the key things about this communication is that it is reliable and intelligible. None of this requires it to be performative. You do not need to cry to tell a woman that you’re feeling sad. You do not need to shout to tell her that you’re angry or laugh giddily to tell her that you’re happy. There is substantial individual variation, of course, but it is, in general, quite sufficient to simply describe your feelings in kind and magnitude. Things such as, “I’m not looking forward to work today. Nothing’s wrong, I’m just tired and I haven’t had a break in a while,” and “This problem at work is really stressing me. We’re going to be fine, but the customer is losing $1000 a day and calls us like every hour to see how it’s going” are usually quite sufficient, so long as they’re said with an intonation consonant with the meaning. (All bets are off if you sound like an android when you speak.)

This communicates what she needs to know in order to be a loving wife who works with you to try to make a happy household in which you are raising happy children. However much you deal with your own problems, doing so will inevitably use some of the resources you have for dealing with other problems such as family members making mistakes and being annoying or hurtful or whatever; when they know that you’re dealing with something big they can take extra trouble to not bother you and be extra tolerant if you snap. This is exactly the same as how you treat a person who has a headache or a cold with extra care and are more tolerant—which is why it’s important to tell people when you have a headache or a cold.

But that’s the thing—you want to tell them. The goal is not to simply give up all control and show people exactly how you’re feeling. You want to communicate like a rational human being who trusts the people to whom he is communicating.

And, indeed, this is attractive to women. If you communicate in a controlled way, she will feel that she is able to actually bond with you and form a relationship with you but will not feel that you are weak. Indeed; by letting her know how you feel, she is better able to gauge your strength. Weak people need to conceal their weakness for fear that it will be exploited, just as injured animals like to curl up in a place where no one can get at them and snarl viciously at anything that comes near so it doesn’t get closer. If you do not communicate at all, that can come across as being afraid of her getting close to you, which is weakness. Which is fair, because it often is. It is only strong people who are willing to be vulnerable. The key to the whole thing is: vulnerable in a rational, self-controlled way. What women want is communication, not emotional incontinence.

Online Acrimony

It is much commented on that there is far more anger, acrimony, and ascerbic speech online than in real life. There is, of course, more than one reason for this. Anonymity reducing people’s normal inhibitions is a commonly cited one, and there is, no doubt, some truth to it. Sometimes a lot of truth. But I think that an often under-appreciated aspect to this is the non-interactive nature of online interaction. The people we interact with online don’t react like we’re build to expect them to, and that screws with our social instincts.

In normal human interaction, that is, interactions that take place face-to-face with people in the same place, the person listening reacts to what the other person is saying through body language. But they don’t wait to react; they react while the other person is speaking. And we look for this while we’re speaking. In the normal course of events, the other person’s reactions as we’re talking may well change how we finish our sentences, to say nothing of what the next sentences are. If we are saying something important to us, we look to see that the other person is giving us their full attention—a sign that they understand the importance of what we’re saying. And here’s the crucial part: if we don’t see that they get how important this is, we amplify our intensity.

That might mean using greater volume, or it might mean using intensifiers like “dirty words”, or it might mean intensifying the thing being said. A person might go from “there’s a problem” to “There’s a !@#$ problem” or they might go to “This is a catastrophe.”

If that doesn’t work, the next intensifier available is to indicate that the relationship between the speaker and the person listening is threatened. This will tend to take the form of insults, because a person is only willing to insult someone that they are willing to do without. This is true in theory much more than in practice, of course; a great deal of insulting is really an attempt to signal where things are headed rather than to indicate where they currently are.

If we consider the nature of online interactions, it should immediately jump out that they all lack real-time feedback. But unlike previous technologically-intermediated means of communication, such as books and letters, the online ones feel far more immediate. When you write a book or a letter, you know that, if you get a response, it will be days or weeks in the future. Online, you might receive a reply in the time it takes someone to type a sentence. This can kick our processing of what they say into real-time processing, as we prepare to immediately respond to them. But our real-time processing relies very heavily on the many aspects of communication apart from the words being spoken and it’s easy to forget how much of the person’s response we actually lack.

We lack it first because most of the time we’re using text so there is neither tone nor cadence nor facial expression nor volume conveyed, all of which are very important to understanding how to interpret the words. The other problem is that the space limitations of text mean that we have to pick and choose what we respond to in what the other person said. But this act of picking and choosing, coupled with the lack of facial expressions/body language as they were speaking, means that they got precisely zero feedback on everything else they said.

It is extremely easy, under these circumstances, for people who have shifted into real-time processing to take this as complete indifference to their attempts to communicate the importance of what they were saying. When this happens, their instinct is to do what they would do in person—amplify and exaggerate.

The instinct to exaggerate, here, is really about accuracy within a context. If a person who is hard of hearing doesn’t hear you, the polite thing to do is to repeat yourself. If you’ve ever had a loved one who suffered from hearing loss in the age before ubiquitous hearing aids, this might get to the point of almost shouting into the person’s ear so they can hear you. In like manner, if you say that a problem is a problem and the other person pays no attention, and you say it’s a catastrophe and they pay no attention, and finally you say that the world is about to end and they finally rouse themselves to listen to you, the intention is to clearly communicate that there is a problem, not to stimulate them into a panicked rush. (This is distinct from people who use exaggeration in order to achieve disproportionate effects, but these people usually start off exaggerating, they don’t start off reasonable. And even the approach meant to accurately calibrate to the insensitivity of the other is fraught with problems, and I’m only trying to describe it, not defend it.)

The other thing that people may do when they perceive that the importance of what they’re saying isn’t being appreciated, you will recall, is to start indicating that the relationship is in danger of being breached. That is, they may start insulting the other person to get their attention.

I suspect that this explains more than a little bit of the acrimony that we see online.

Clearing Plates at Family Gatherings

In America, Thanksgiving and Christmas tend to be occasions for family gatherings with a large meal. People often talk while they eat, and when people are done eating and only talking, it is extremely common to see the women of the family get up and start clearing the plates away while the males continue to talk. Around this time, a few unpleasant women who don’t understand human beings very well will write articles complaining about this. So for the sake of young people who might be taken in by one of those articles, I will explain what’s going on.

Unless you’re really into cooking, making thanksgiving dinner isn’t actually a lot of work. It takes perhaps fifteen minutes to put the turkey on a tray, season the skin, and put it in the oven at 325F for 3-5 hours (depending on size). Mashed potatoes or if you have better taste mashed sweet potatoes are another fifteen minutes of work. Bread, you can easily just buy at the store. If you’re not making it from scratch, add another fifteen minutes for the stuffing. Putting that all together, it’s an hour of work for a single person. That’s not trivial, but it’s not that much work. I’ve done significantly more work than that for minor dinner parties, and it’s not more work than one might do barbecuing food at a cookout. Cleaning up a dozen plates from a table is, if you’re doing it yourself, perhaps five minutes. If you have a dishwasher (as everyone who writes articles complaining that men talk instead of helping does), add another five minutes for scraping food off of plates and loading them into the dishwasher. If this is a major amount of work for you which might break you unless you get help, as the kids would say, you’re NGMI (not gonna make it).

Of course, that’s not what’s going on. Except for the occasional host with significant health problems—and the family member with significant health problems almost never hosts family gatherings—the host of family gatherings is not overwhelmed by the work involved and doesn’t need help. The reason why all the women help is because this is an expression of female social bonding. Identifying ways to help each other and helping unasked is a way that women reinforce their social bonds. When there’s nothing to do, asking, “what can I do to help” is a next best thing, which is why you will see it asked even when there’s obviously nothing to do to help. The point isn’t the actual work, but the affirmation of the social bond in the offer. This is also why the typical response is, “there’s nothing right now,” followed by a list of what’s going on. The point of this is not the actual inventory, but the affirmation of the bond by sharing concerns and implicitly inviting the other woman to help monitor them. (There’s actually a bit of an art to this because a woman can give offense by usurping some decision-making in her effort to help; young women generally watch their elders navigate this and learn the art by the time they’re old enough to take part as adults.) This is why when one woman gets up and starts to collect plates, the rest of the women jump up and start collecting plates too—they are affirming their social bonds by all working together.

This type of social bonding is markedly different from male social bonding, which can be readily observed at a cookout, where it’s traditionally the males who do most of the work. Males can, without giving offense, make a perfunctory offer of assistance to the male host, but mostly they don’t because assuming that another man can handle everything is a sign of respect. Further letting the male host do whatever grilling and other work is involved in hosting without interference is also an implicit sign of respect. Males will, however, make a point of hanging out with and talking to the host, because conversation about interesting subjects is a primary way adult males affirm social bonds.

So at the big family meal, when the women clean the plates together and the males keep talking, both are engaging in their sex’s typical form of social bonding. The two groups bond with each other by the men showing appreciation for the (in truth, quite small) labor of the women, and the women bond with the males by enabling the conversation which is maintained. The males can be rude by taking the generosity of the women for granted, the women can be rude by interrupting the conversation with work that can easily be left for after people are done talking.

The unpleasant women who write articles complaining about this dynamic at social gatherings are people with poorly developed social skills that don’t know how male social dynamics work and who assume that female social dynamics are the only social dynamics and so regard males as dysfunctional women. So they’re trying to guilt them into being functional women. (They’re also trying to parasocially bond with other women with poor social skills who don’t understand the full range of social dynamics by communal complaining.)

What Makes an Expert

I was recently re-watching the 2009 documentary Fat Head, mostly for nostalgia because I enjoyed it and it did me a lot of good back when I watched it circa 2010.

If you haven’t seen it and are curious, it’s available (officially, from its distributor) on YouTube. (Weirdly, it’s age-restricted so I can’t embed it.)

This was back when the documentary Super Size Me blaming McDonalds for people being fat was only five years old and people still remembered it. Fat Head was a response-documentary criticizing Super Size Me, but it actually spent more of its time discussing the lipid hypothesis (the idea that fat and especially saturated fat causes heart disease) and the problems with it. Throughout the documentary, Tom Naughton (the filmmaker and narrator) continually refers to “the experts,” by which he mostly means the people who give official advice, such as the USDA giving food recommendations or various medical organizations telling everyone to reduce their saturated fat intake as much as possible.

“Expert,” of course, ordinarily means a person who is extremely knowledgeable in a subject or very good at it. But “expert” is also a social designation for special people to whom ordinary people are supposed to defer, generally with the assumption that they are expert in the first sense. But this introduces a problem: how do you know that someone is an expert in the first sense?

The easy way to do this is to be an expert yourself. Expertise will generally be good at recognizing expertise, as well as recognizing what is not expertise. That’s great, but if you’re an expert yourself you don’t need to know who else is an expert so you can defer to them.

So what if you’re not an expert?

Well, it gets a lot harder.

You can, of course, punt the problem to someone that you trust, but that is a general solution: it works for literally every question. How do you calculate the circumference of a circle given its diameter? Ask someone you trust.

But let’s assume, for the sake of discussion, that you want to find an expert and aren’t going to just have someone else do the work. How can you do this—again, assuming that you, yourself, are not an expert?

It certainly cannot be in the same way that an expert would, that is, by evaluating how the person does what they do. There is something left, though it’s not nearly so efficient: you can see whether the person can achieve what only an expert could achieve.

In most of the places where this is possible, it’s fairly obvious. If you want to know if a man is an expert archer, you ask him to shoot at a few things which are very difficult to hit. If you want to know if a man is an expert lock pick, you ask him to pick a difficult lock.

There are some intermediate situations, which do not admit of demonstrations which only take a moment. If you want to know if a man is an expert painter, it is not practical to ask him to go to all of the trouble of painting a painting in your sight. But you can ask him to show you paintings which he has painted, and then after he shows you some impressive paintings you have only the ordinary problem of finding out whether he’s an honest man and really is the one who painted them.

But then we come to problems which are far more difficult. How can you tell if a man is an expert teacher? The only practical effect of a good teacher is a learned student. If you have access to the students to test them, you mostly can only tell in the negative—a student who obviously knows nothing—since the whole reason to seek out a teacher is to be taught. (There are exceptions for things such as being an expert in Greek but not in teaching Greek, and you want to find an excellent teacher for your child. Let us set that aside as a special case which is easier than the one we’re trying to deal with.) However, even in the best case this is not a pure evaluation of the teacher because the end results also depends upon the quality of the student. This is clear in the case of athletics. Some people have bodies which are proportioned exceedingly well for the sport and when this is married to a disposition which finds physical activities intuitive, they would come to be very good in their sport regardless of who their teacher is; an excellent teacher will make them better but a bad teacher will still make them good (unless he gets them injured).

Medicine is an interesting hybrid of this. It is possible to evaluate a trauma surgeon mostly based on results because how well one patches up a man after a knife would or a gun shot or a bear mauling does not depend very much on the constitution of the victim. It does depend on the wound, of course, but it’s not that hard to evaluate wounds based on criteria such as their rate of blood flow or the amount of the victim which is missing.

It is nowhere near as possible to evaluate an internal medicine doctor’s treatment of chronic conditions. The human body is an unbelievably complex thing—I mean that literally; most people can’t believe the complexity involved. Biology keeps on making new discoveries that things are more complex than previous believed. All of this complexity can go wrong, and there are far fewer kinds of symptoms. In short, we have no way of evaluating what is actually wrong with a patient or how bad it actually is. Not everything is fixable; how much that doesn’t get better is the fault of the doctor and how much is the fault of the disease? We have no way of knowing, certainly not for the purpose of evaluating the doctor.

So what about the kinds of experts who give health and nutrition advice?

The first thing to notice is that the time scales are not favorable. Being healthy over decades is a thing that takes decades, and that’s a really long time over which to evaluate someone’s advice in order to determine whether their advice is worth following. And we’ve also got a problem much like in evaluating internal medicine doctors: we’re talking about how to optimize an unbelievably complex system (the human body). Worse, though, is that this kind of advice is general, and the population itself varies. There’s absolutely no reason to believe that the same dietary advice is equally good advice for all members of the population. For all we know, Frenchmen do better eating baguettes than Germans do and Germans are healthier eating sausages than Frenchmen are. For all we know, there might be two brothers and one does well on pasta while the other will get fat and sick on it. At least internal medicine doctors treat individual patients; experts who give general advice on health and nutrition give the same advice to everyone. That might be fine—no one should eat uranium, for example—but it’s not obviously fine. For all we know (without be experts ourselves) universal dietary guidelines are intrinsically a bad idea that no true expert would do, just as no true fencing expert fences with reverse grip or by holding the tip and trying to thrust the hilt into his opponent.

But even if we grant the idea, for some reason, that a true expert would give general dietary advice, how do we evaluate the expertise of a particular expert giving it? The effect that we could measure would be the superior health and fitness of the people who follow this advice to what they would have had if they didn’t follow this advice.

OK, but how on earth do you measure that? How do you identify the people who follow the advice. How do you figure out how healthy they would have been had they not followed the advice?

That last part is important because it’s extremely easy for advice which does nothing to select for people who are generally superior. To give a silly but clear example: if you give advice on how to grow taller and it’s to dunk a basketball ten times a day, every day, and then measure the average height of the adherents and the average height of the non-adherents, you’ll find that the adherents are, in fact, taller. No taller than they would have been otherwise, but certainly taller than the non-adherents. Or if your advice for strength is to pick up a three hundred pound rock and carry it five hundred feet each day, you’ll certainly find that the adherents are stronger than the non-adherents, since only very strong people will even try to follow this advice. In like manner, if you recommend that people eat a pound of arugula a day, it’s quite possible that only people who are very healthy would even consider putting the stuff in their mouth given how much (if you don’t disguise its flavor with oil or sugar) it tastes like poison. (Because it is; the bitter taste of many plants come from natural pesticides they make in order to dissuade bugs from eating them. These are just poisons that have little to no effect on us since we’re mammals and not insects.)

The basic answer is that you can’t. Not to any important degree.

There’s a related issue to the question of “how can you tell if someone is an expert?” and that’s “how does someone become an expert?” It’s related because, oversimplifying, the way you become an expert is to evaluate whether you can do what an expert can do and then change what you’re doing until you can do those things. If there’s no way to evaluate whether you’re getting better at the things an expert could do, there’s no way to tell whether the things that you’re doing are making you any better, which means that there’s no way to actually become an expert. (I’ve oversimplified quite a bit; this really deserves its own blog post.)

So what does that mean for fields where it’s not possible to tell who’s an expert?

Effectively, it means that there are no experts in that field.

The Problem With Stopping Bullying

A little while ago, I was watching a Chris Williamson podcast with a guest who studies bullying. One interesting thing about it was the finding that bullying is primarily among popular people. Which makes sense, if you think about it, because they are actually a threat to the status of others and so putting them down can actually accomplish something. But the thing I found really curious was the discussion of how to get people to stop bullying, because both of them didn’t seem to notice that within a secular framework, this is basically impossible.

It’s impossible for the simple reason that bullying works. When you are vying for social status with other people, bullying can discourage them and get them to stop trying to be popular too, paving the way for you to be popular. This isn’t the thing one typically sees in movies where a big guy picks on some small kid. It’s not that that never happens, but it doesn’t usually happen like in the movies. That kind of thing really is just simple theft—you don’t threaten to beat a kid up for his lunch money because it brings you a warm glow of satisfaction or makes you popular with others, you do it because you want more money and don’t want to put in the effort to get it honestly. In movies, mostly the bullies are just externalized versions of a person’s own conscience, and pick on him for his vices or at least the things he doesn’t like about himself because Hollywood writers are bad people and their consciences frequently bother them so they want to externalize their conscience so that they can eventually beat it up to the cheers of onlookers.

In real life, bullying is primarily done among popular kids because they have something of value—social status. Bullying them makes them feel bad and retreat from the things that make them popular. This kind of bullying is covert—in real life you don’t get crowds cheering for you when you bully someone, so you have to do your best to keep anyone from knowing what you’re doing. (Or else tell them stories which justify what you’re doing as protecting yourself or, at the worst, justice for what was done to you.)

In this context, bullying works. You can, through bullying people, make them feel bad. People who feel bad are not as charismatic. They don’t always show up to parties. People stop liking them as much. When you’re around and as charismatic as ever, your popularity goes up.

Worse for the people who want to stop bullying, bullying is one of the more subtle activities human beings engage in. If you try to have any kind of official anti-bullying campaign, some of the first people to use it will be the bullies. They will accuse their victims of bullying them, or the more sophisticated ones will provoke their victims into some kind of retaliation then bring that retaliation to the anti-bullying authority to get the victim punished.

All of this is especially true of female bullies, since females tend to take advantage of other females’ extreme sensitivity to rejection by females. Skilled girls and women can be artists with this kind of subtle signaling which is virtually undetectable to anyone else.

For these and other reasons, bullying is something that authorities (for the most part) can’t directly stop. But what you can’t directly stop you may be able to indirectly stop—you can try to persuade people to not bully others. The problem with this is that bullying works. Asking people to not bully others amounts to asking them to forgo a benefit. Why should they do this?

Within a secular context, now that quasi-religious feelings for nations have been discredited and no one cares, the only viable way of getting people to change their behavior is to show them why it’s to their own benefit to do or not do whatever it is you want them to do or not do. Hence, with drugs, you clearly communicate all of the many side-effects of drug abuse. To try to stop kids from having children out of wedlock, you try to persuade them that having children will suck and tell them in detail about every STD you can think of.

But bullying works and, if the bully isn’t caught, it has no immediate side-effects for the bully. All you can do is to ask them to forgo a benefit to themselves for the sake of another. But the idea that you should love people who can’t give you anything is a religious proposition; it stands or falls on the truth of metaphysical propositions such as God loving us and creating us to love each other (where love is defined as willing the good of the other for his sake). That’s not exclusively a Christian idea, but it is very far from a universal idea.

Feelings and Facts Can Be the Same Conversation

Conversations about feelings have something of a low reputation and not entirely undeservedly. People who are bad at emotional regulation will talk about little else besides feelings and generally in a very unproductive way. Further, self-control is an important skill which has been rightly lauded by religions and philosophical systems alike. If you want to do something which takes precision, such as building a bridge or disinfecting surgical equipment, “facts not feels” will lead to more success.

All of this is true, and I very much prefer conversations about facts, even if personal facts, to conversations about feelings. But all this misses something.

Conversations about facts and conversations about feelings can be the same conversation in different languages.

The reason for this is that emotions are, in their essence, a kind of sense perception. They’re not a bodily sense perception like sight, smell, etc. but they are a kind of sense perception. Fear is the perception of danger. Anger is the perception of injustice. Gratitude is the perception of received benefit. And so on.

Feelings can be mistaken, of course, but so can bodily senses. We can think we felt something small touch us but when we look there’s nothing there. We can think we heard somebody say something but when we ask them what it was they said that they didn’t make a sound. There’s an entire field of making things that we see incorrectly called “optical illusions.” Our emotions are not infallible, but neither are any of our other senses. All of life requires the humility to acknowledge our fallibility.

When you consider a discussion of feelings in this light, as long as the discussion is between two people with enough humility to admit they could be mistaken, a discussion of feelings is really a discussion of the things that the feelings are perceptions of. If an object caused high amplitude sound waves in the air, among non-narcissists, “a high-energy sound was just produced” and “I heard a loud noise” is saying essentially the same thing. It is true that the latter involves the first person singular pronoun, but that’s merely giving you the added information of what instrument registered the high-energy sound. This can actually be quite useful because every instrument has its strengths and weaknesses and knowing which instrument produced the measurement described allows the other person to calibrate accordingly.

This is true of feelings, too. “In the last month, you washed the dishes three quarters of one time and swept the floors one quarter of one time” and “I’m feeling alone with the housework” differ somewhat in their precision, but they are describing the same thing. (And before you get any ideas, I do most of the housework in my house.)

It is possible, then, when someone initiates a conversation about feelings, to have an actual conversation with them. That won’t work if they have no humility, but no conversations really work with the proud, since pride tends towards solipsism and conversation requires acknowledging the existence of the other person. But most people have at least some humility, and it just takes practice to recognize it in people who are talking about their feelings. In some cases people will even talk about their feelings in order to present their observations more gently; to continue with the above example, they would consider the recitation of facts about the frequency of housework to be likely to come across like a personal attack, whereas if they instead focus the conversation on their feelings they expect it to come across like less of a personal attack. This can work very badly when done with someone else whose conversational style takes facts as non-aggressive and discussions of feelings as nebulous and dire. (This kind of mismatch can happen between anyone, though it is most stereotypically between two people where one has a higher-than-average number of X chromosomes and the other a higher-than-average number of Y chromosomes. (Bear in mind that, across the entire population, the average number of X chromosomes is, roughly, 1.5 and the average number of Y chromosomes is, roughly, 0.5))

The good news is that, like all differences in language, it is possible to become “bi-lingual.” It takes practice and discipline, not to mention humility, but a person who tends to either communication style can learn to understand the other one, and even learn to communicate in that style. It’s ideal if both people learn it, of course, but if one isn’t strong enough to do it it will still work pretty well if the stronger one learns how to do it and condescends to the weaker one. (I mean condescend in the etymological sense, “to come down to be with”.)

Psycho-Analysis Began in Hypnosis

In my (low-key) quest to understand how on earth Freud’s theories were ever respected, I’ve recently read Five Lectures on Psycho-Analysis. It’s definitely been interesting. (If you don’t know, this is the transcript of five lectures he gave on five consecutive days at Clark University in Worcester, Massachusetts in 1909 which were meant to give a concise summary of Psycho-Analysis.)

Something I did not realize, but which makes perfect sense in retrospect, is that Psycho-Analysis began in hypnosis. A tiny bit of background is necessary, here: In the 1800s and early 1900s, the term “hysteria” seems to refer to any idiopathic problem in women with severe physical symptoms. Basically, when a woman developed bad symptoms and called in a doctor and he could find no physical cause, the diagnosis was “hysteria,” which basically meant “I don’t know, in a woman.” At this point, since the symptoms don’t have physical causes it is assumed that they must have mental causes and so doctors of the mind would step in to try to help, supposing, of course, that the patient or her family could afford it.

Freud begins with an interesting story about a patient that a colleague of his, Dr. Breuer, was treating. It was a young woman under great stress (nursing her dying father) who started developing a bunch of really bad symptoms that sound, to my ear, like a series of small strokes. She couldn’t use her right arm or leg for a while, sometimes she couldn’t use her left side, she forgot her native language (German) and could only speak English, etc. She also developed a severe inability to drink water and survived fro several weeks on melons and other high-water foods. And here’s where it gets interesting. Dr. Breuer hypnotized her and in a hypnotic state she related the story of having gone into a companion’s room and seen the woman’s dog drinking from a glass. This disgusted her terribly but she gave no indication of it because she didn’t want to offend the woman. He then gave the young woman a glass of water, brought her out of hypnosis, and she was able to drink normally from then on.

Freud moved away from hypnosis for several reasons, but the big one seems to be that most people can’t be hypnotized, which makes it a therapeutic tool of dubious value. The particulars of how he moved away is interesting, but I’ll get to that in a little bit. Before that, I want to focus on the hypnosis.

The history of hypnosis is interesting in itself, but a bit complex, and the relevant part is really how it was more popularly perceived than by what it was intended as. In its early stages, hypnosis was seem as something very different from normal waking life and, as a result, excited an enormous amount of interest from people who desired secret knowledge of the universe’s inner secrets. There were plenty of people who wanted to believe in a hidden world that they could access if only they had the key (spurred on, I suspect, by the many discoveries of the microscope in the late 1600s and the continued discoveries as a result of better and better microscopes). Hypnotism, where a man’s mind seemed to alter to a completely different state, and in particular where it could receive commands that it would obey without remembering in a subsequent waking state, was perfect for just such a belief. Here there seemed to be another behind, behind the mind we observe, which seemed to govern the observable mind’s operation. This is the sort of stuff out of which real power is based—if you can control the real source of the mind, you can control the mind!

This context really makes Pysho-Analysis’s model of the compartmentalized mind and further its insistence on the power of the sub-conscious mind make sense.

As I said, Freud abandoned hypnotism, and the means by which he did it really should have been a tip-off to his whole theory being wrong. What led him to discard hypnotism were some experiments he became aware of in which a person who could not remember what he did under hypnosis could be induced, without any further hypnosis, to remember. Freud only took this instrumentally rather than considering that it undermined the whole idea of the powerful subconscious and went about bringing up the “repressed” memories which were (putatively) causing physical symptoms by talking with the patient without hypnotism. I suppose that the idea of this secret knowledge was too attractive to give up.

How to Balance Gratitude With Ambition

I was watching a Chris Williamson Q&A video recently and a question he was asked was how to balance gratitude with ambition (or aspiration for improvement, if you dislike the term ambition). The exact phrasing of the question was:

How do I manage the dichotomy between being grateful for how far I’ve come and wanting to become more? The dichotomy between working for my future and being present in the moment.

There are several answer to this, and the thing is, they’re all primarily religious. It’s actually kind of interesting how often hard-won, top-level secular wisdom is beginning religious education. The Jewish sabbath is exactly this. God created the heavens and the earth in six days, and on the seventh day God rested, so human beings will work for six days and rest on the seventh. (Bear in mind that rest implies contemplation, not merely sleeping.) There you go, there’s your management of the dichotomy between working and gratitude. (The Christian moving of the day of rest to Sunday is an interesting and rich topic, but all of that rich symbolism doesn’t materially affect the current subject.) To put this in secular terms, a regular 6-to-1 balance of time dedicated to work with time dedicated to contemplation will keep your balance. If you keep it regular (that is, according to a rule), it will ensure that the effects of contemplation do not wear off. And guess what: you need to impose rules on yourself to make yourself do it because human beings don’t perfectly auto-regulate. (Just don’t make the rules so rigid you can’t live; the sabbath was made for man, not man for the sabbath.)

Another answer, here, is to keep God always in mind. This will make you strive to be perfect as your Father in heaven is perfect and also make you grateful for all that He’s already given you.

Here’s where Jordan Peterson’s language of “God is the highest good” falls a bit short, since keeping the highest good in mind will stimulate ambition, but it doesn’t tend nearly so much to gratitude. For gratitude you need to keep in mind the nothingness from which you came and which you could, apart from the positive action of The Good, become again. This requires a leap of faith that the world is not evil, though. If you can do this, you’re not going to be secular for long, and the whole exercise of trying to put this into secular language will be unnecessary. If you can’t take this leap of faith that the world exists because of good, then you’ll never actually be grateful anyway. People try to use “grateful” as an intransitive verb, but it’s not. It’s a transitive verb. You don’t have to conceive of God as a person to be grateful to Him, though it helps. But if the world is just a cruel joke with no punchline which no one told, gratitude is nonsensical. But here’s the thing: if you aren’t sure whether life is a cruel joke with no punchline that no one has told, that is equally paralyzing.

To see why, consider this thought experiment: you receive a text message from a friend which says something complementary about you, but there are enough odd word choices that you think it might just be his phone unlocked in his pocket interacting with auto-correct. Try to feel grateful for this message which you think might be a real compliment and might just be random noise that accidentally looks like a message. You will find that you can’t do it.

Nevertheless, it can still be interesting to say what is true, even if it will do no one any good: the way you keep perspective is by comparing, not to one thing, but to two things. If you want to keep perspective on your achievements, you must compare them both to the fullness of what you can achieve as well as to the nothing which is the least you could have achieved. Comparing to only one will not give you a proper perspective, because neither, on its own, is the full picture. Only by looking at the full picture will you have a correct perspective on where your achievements are within it. This is as true of metaphorical photographs as it is of literal photographs.